How the verdicts work
Every verdict compares two numbers: what a franchise paid for a player in a season, and what that season's output was worth. It's a fan's value-for-money view, not a judgement of anyone's talent or effort.
1. What was paid
Cost is the player's purse value for that season (auction price, retention fee, trade or replacement fee) plus match fees where they apply (₹7.5 lakh per appearance from 2025). A player bought at a mega auction keeps that price for every season of the cycle unless it changed. Seasons paid in US dollars (2008–2013) are converted at that year's average rupee rate.
2. What was delivered
Each season's output is turned into points from ball-by-ball data:
- Batting: 1 point per run, plus or minus half a point for every run scored faster or slower than the league strike rate that season.
- Bowling: 25 points per wicket, plus or minus runs saved or leaked against the league economy rate.
- Fielding: 10 per catch, 15 per stumping, 15 per direct run out, 8 per assisted run out.
3. Fair price
A player's fair price is his share of all points scored that season, multiplied by everything franchises spent that season. If a player produced 1% of the league's points, his fair price is 1% of the league's total spend.
4. The verdict
Value delivered = fair price ÷ price paid.
- Steal: 3× or more, and above-median output.
- Value: 1.5× or more.
- Fair: 0.67× to 1.5×.
- Overpaid: 0.33× to 0.67× (or lower, if he cost under ₹2 crore).
- Robbery: under 0.33× and he cost ₹2 crore or more.
- Not enough games: fewer than 5 matches. Too little to judge fairly.
- Paid, didn't play: cost ₹1 crore or more and played no matches (often injury or unavailability).
- Fee not disclosed: no public record of the fee.
5. Cost per run, wicket and more
Cost per run is shown only after 60 balls faced; cost per wicket and per dot ball only after 60 balls bowled, so a single cameo doesn't produce a silly number.
Limits
- Leadership, captaincy and dressing-room value are not measured.
- Some early-season and replacement fees were never published.
- Points reward output, not match situation. A slow 30 that saved a collapse scores like any slow 30.
Spotted a wrong price or stat? Tell us and we'll fix it.